InsightHireHelp Center

Structured interviews

Give interviewers a shared plan, collect independent scorecards, and act on the panel's feedback.

Availability: Structured interviews (kits, scorecards and the feedback queue) are an optional feature. Standard interview scheduling works without them.

A structured interview gives candidates for the same role a consistent set of job-related questions and criteria. An interview kit holds the plan. A scorecard records one interviewer's ratings, notes and recommendation.

Who can do what

  • Hiring team members create and edit interview kits and scorecard templates under Templates → Interview kits.
  • Organization Admins also turn feedback enforcement on or off and can create a job's feedback template from scratch.
  • Interviewers fill in the scorecards assigned to them. Until you submit yours, you don't see what the rest of the panel said. People who manage the job can see the panel at any time.
  • Moving or rejecting a candidate from a scorecard happens only when the person submitting manages that job. Anyone else's yes or no is recorded as a recommendation and the candidate stays where they are.
  • Org Admins, recruiters and hiring managers see the Team tab on the feedback page.

Create a scorecard template

  1. Open Templates → Interview kits.
  2. Under Scorecard templates, select New template, or Seed default for a starter template.
  3. Enter a Template name.
  4. For each competency, enter a label and an optional description of what good evidence looks like.
  5. Untick Required for anything interviewers may skip. Use Add competency for more rows.
  6. Select Save template.

Start with a small number of distinct competencies. Avoid rating the same quality under several labels.

Build an interview kit

  1. Open Templates → Interview kits and select New kit.
  2. Give it a Name that identifies the interview type, for example "Technical screen".
  3. Add a short Description and the Interviewer prep briefing.
  4. Pick the Scorecard template.
  5. Under Suggested questions, use Add question for each question in the order to ask it. Fill in Linked competency (optional) to tie a question to a scorecard item.
  6. Select Save kit.

For more detail, see Interview kits.

Assign a kit and scorecards

  1. Schedule the interview. See Schedule interviews.
  2. Pick the Interview kit (optional).
  3. Save. Scorecards are assigned to you and to every interviewer whose email matches a teammate.

A job can also have a default Feedback template. It shows at the top of the candidate's Interview feedback panel. People who manage the job can use Choose template or Change. Organization Admins can also use Create new template or Use default template.

Submit feedback

Feedback is due the moment an interview ends. Your scorecards are under Hiring → Feedback on the My queue tab, grouped Overdue (ended more than a day ago), Due now and Upcoming. The same items appear as Write feedback tasks on Home and as a Write your feedback link on the interview row in the job's Schedule tab.

  1. Open the scorecard from any of those places. Before the interview, the link reads Open prep and shows the kit's prep notes and questions.
  2. Rate each competency using evidence from the conversation. Drafts save automatically.
  3. Add short notes that explain each rating.
  4. Choose an overall recommendation: Strong yes, Yes, No decision, No or Strong no.
  5. Read the What happens next line above the Submit button. A yes moves the candidate to the next stage of the interview plan. A no rejects them and sends the stage's rejection email. Leave Apply this when I submit on to let it happen, or turn it off to record your feedback only.
  6. Submit. You then see what the rest of the panel said and can jump to your next scorecard.

The decision applies once per scorecard and shows on the candidate's timeline. If the candidate is already in the last stage or their application is closed, the line tells you and nothing changes. If you don't manage the job, your recommendation is saved and the people who manage the job decide the move.

Choose which rejection email each interview stage sends under Settings → Pipelines (or in the job's interview plan). With none set, your first active rejection template is used.

When you mark an interview Completed on the Schedule tab, any missing scorecards are created and you are offered yours right away. Your past scorecards are on the Submitted tab.

Chase missing feedback

The Team tab on Hiring → Feedback lists every interview on your jobs that has ended with scorecards still outstanding, and who on the panel has or has not written up.

  • Nudge re-sends the reminder email to one interviewer. One automatic reminder also goes out 24 hours after the interview ends.
  • Add interviewer requests a scorecard from a teammate who sat in but was not on the invite.
  • Each interview row on the job's Schedule tab shows Feedback 2/3 and who is still owed.

Run the debrief

  1. Check the panel signal on the Review board card, for example Panel: 3 yes · 1 no or 2 scorecards outstanding.
  2. Review where the panel agrees and disagrees in the panel view on the candidate's profile.
  3. Ask interviewers to point to evidence, not intuition.
  4. Decide the next stage based on the role's requirements.
  5. Record the decision by moving the card on the Review board.

If feedback enforcement is on and scorecards are missing, the move is blocked and the board names who still owes feedback.

Use feedback enforcement carefully

Organization Admins can stop candidates advancing while completed interviews still have missing scorecards. The switch is Require interview feedback before pipeline advancement under Templates → Interview kits → Feedback enforcement.

  1. Run a small pilot without enforcement.
  2. Confirm that interviewers can find and submit their scorecards.
  3. Set a clear deadline for feedback.
  4. Turn on enforcement only after the workflow works reliably.
  5. Tell recruiters how to find and resolve missing feedback.

To move the candidate after the debrief, see Review and move candidates forward.

Check that interviewers rate consistently

Once interviewers have submitted a handful of scorecards, open Analytics → Interviewer calibration to see who rates higher or lower than their peers, and who often differs from the panel or the final decision. See Interviewer calibration.